Here’s Why You May Want to Talk to That Debt Collector Before Tax Season Ends

Tax season is like Christmas to debt collectors, one agency head says, but that can be good news for borrowers. Here's why.

Here’s something your may not know: Tax season is like Christmas for debt collectors.

In fact, as president of a national debt collection company, I can tell you some agencies will collect as much money from February through May as in the remaining eight months of the year. Why?

Well, the first reason is a bit obvious: Many consumers in debt will receive a tax refund and go on to use that money to pay off their delinquent debt. Second, many debt collectors are good at what they do and want to help consumers resolve their outstanding liabilities. They’re willing to work out or negotiate a payment plan the consumer now has the ability to repay. (And, yes, that means the debt collector who’s been contacting you may be willing to settle up for less than what you owe.)

So who has the upper hand when it comes to getting debt repaid during tax season? If the cards are played right, both the consumer and the debt collector come out ahead.

During this time of year, consumers are generally going to come across two types of debt collectors. The first is a debt collector who understands a consumer has access to a limited tax refund — and is potentially trying to pay off a multitude of debts. This collector will be looking to help the consumer resolve as many debts as possible with the funds they receive back from Uncle Sam. The other type of debt collector will hold their ground, knowing the consumer has funds to pay off a singular debt, and will ultimately refuse to negotiate payment for a lesser amount. Odds are consumers will run across both types of debt collectors during this time of year.

What Drives a Debt Collector’s Settlement Stance?

If you have an outstanding debt, it is important to understand the delicate balance collectors face during tax season. Several factors determine what debt collectors ultimately are able to do for consumers looking to settle a debt for less than what is owed.

The main factor is the client whose behalf they are collecting on. Settlements live and die with the requirements of a client; either they authorize the debt collector to offer a settlement or they do not. If the client allows for settlements, it is dependent upon the agency as to when, where and/or how they offer one. Some agencies may only offer settlements for accounts on file for 60 days or more, whereas other companies will offer settlements on the first day the account gets to their office.

The Odds Are in Your Favor

It is more probable than not that during tax season a debt collector has the ability to offer a settlement. Contrary to popular belief, debt collectors do not like to turn away money, especially this time of year. While one may hold firm for a while, when approached with a reasonable settlement offer, they will generally do what is in their power to get it approved. They may be willing to waive excess interest, late fees and other non-principal-related charges before tax season is up as well.

On the flip side, consumers should not expect a debt collector to take “pennies on the dollar” to settle accounts. Even if their agency did directly purchase the debt — which happens less frequently these days — the debt collector you’re dealing with isn’t the person who directly bought the debt, and they are going to be required to follow the guidelines set forth by their employer. You can find more tips for negotiating with a collector here.

The Bottom Line

Tax season can be a mutually beneficial time for the consumer and the debt collector, so if you’re hoping to shore up an outstanding account and/or are looking to strike a deal, now may be the right time to do so.

Just keep in mind, if one side tries too hard to “game” the other, an opportunity to resolve a bad debt will likely fall through and that bill will remain delinquent. At the end of the day, if consumers and debt collectors engage in a professional and respectful dialogue, it’s likely they’ll reach a resolution that benefits all parties.

[Editor’s Note: A collection account can wind up hurting your credit score. To see where yours stands, you can view your free credit report snapshot, updated every 14 days, on]

This story is an Op/Ed contribution to and does not necessarily represent the views of the company or its partners.

Image: filadendron

The post Here’s Why You May Want to Talk to That Debt Collector Before Tax Season Ends appeared first on

Help! A Debt Collector Isn’t Working With Me


Paying off a debt can unfortunately be easier said than done. Usually the struggle is related to the debtor’s financial well-being. (You probably wouldn’t owe money if you could pay it back, right?) But there are times when a collector can gum up the works.

You’ll want to, of course, verify all collection accounts before paying. But if you do owe, here are a few worst-case scenarios you may run across when trying to repay a debt and what you can do.

1. They Won’t Accept Payments

There’s no specific provision in the Fair Debt Collections Practices Act stipulating that a debtee accept payment, said Troy Doucet, a consumer attorney in Columbus, Ohio — though you’ll rarely, if ever, encounter one who will give you a hard time about paying in full. “Most of them get a piece of the pie,” he said, so debt collectors will be more than happy to take the payment (and their commission).

It’s more likely you’ll run into problems when trying to pay a debt for less than you owe. And, unfortunately, “so long as the debt collector is asking for the correct amount of money, they’re not legally obligated to negotiate with you,” Doucet said.

You might up your odds of negotiating a payment plan by asking questions, taking notes, addressing issues calmly and seeking outside assistance from a reputable credit repair company. And if you are dealing with a rogue collector who for whatever reason won’t let you pay back in full, you may want to contact a consumer attorney. He or she could potentially file a claim against the party in question for violating other provisions of the FDCPA or for being in breach of contract, Doucet said.

2. You Can’t Track Them Down

Your credit report(s) should list any collection account reported to the credit bureau in question. A telephone number is also provided with each account when it’s available, so you might want to pull a copy from each credit reporting agency to start. If a number is listed, great. If not, you can try searching online for the phone number, email or address of the company on your report. You can also try contacting your original creditor, Doucet said. They may be able to verify who they sold the debt to and provide you with the proper contact information.

If the debt collector is not open to negotiating, the original creditor might still have an interest in the debt and be willing to work out or facilitate a payment plan, Doucet said. You can try disputing the information with the credit bureaus, citing your inability to pay, he added. They will kickstart an investigation and could incite the collector to settle or at the very least turn up some valuable contact information.

Remember, collection accounts can do big damage to your credit scores, so it’s in your best interest to get them resolved or, if they’re inaccurate, removed. You can go here to learn more about disputing credit report errors. And if your credit has suffered due to a collection account, you can improve your scores in the long term by making all future loan payments on time, keeping debt levels low and limiting new credit inquiries until your score rebounds. You can track your progress by viewing your two free credit scores each month on

[Offer: If you need help fixing errors on your credit report, Lexington Law could help you meet your goals. Learn more about them here or call them at (844) 346-3296 for a free consultation.]

More on Credit Reports & Credit Scores:

Image: JackF 

The post Help! A Debt Collector Isn’t Working With Me appeared first on

3 Things to Do Before Calling Back a Debt Collector

Can I Bypass a Debt Collector?

You just listened to the voice mail, and your heart is in your throat. A debt collector called. What now?

Your next step could be the difference between a manageable bump in the road and a years-long nightmare. So here, we’re going to walk you through these critical first few moments.

When a debt collector calls, a million thoughts race through your mind — everything from “I thought I paid that” to “I thought they forgot.” (Rest assured, very few people forget about unpaid bills nowadays.)

Ultimately, your primary goal should be to pay off your debts as smoothly and quickly as possible — as long as you have the means to do so, and the debt really belongs to you. If not, we’ll deal with those possibilities, too.

First and foremost, don’t immediately return the phone call. You have a bunch of homework to do first. But do call. Ignoring a debt collector, even one who is calling in violation of the law, is probably the biggest mistake you can make. The problem, whatever it is, will only get bigger. (Learn more about your debt collection rights here.)

Before the Call 

First, take a deep breath. Next, grab a pen and notebook. Every interaction you have with a debt collector — and frankly, anyone calling about money — needs to be documented. Play the message again and transcribe it; you just never know what may be useful later. Carefully note the time, date, name of caller and any other specifics. You’ve just begun what some folks call a “collections log.”

When you are done, give it a home right near the phone so you can find it easily next time. Yes, you can do this on a digital file if you like, but only if you’re confident in your typing skills and religiously back up data. You don’t want to lose this.

Now it’s time to do some research. You want to be as prepared as you can before you talk to the debt collector. That might mean talking to family members about the debt; going to to see if the debt is on your credit report; or digging through old mail. Get your ducks in a row, as you want as few surprises as possible. This will also help your brain and your heart slow down.

During the Call 

There are several specific things to do (and not do) during the initial debt collector call, but before we get to that, here are two critical things to keep in mind:

  1. Drive the call. Be active, not passive.
  2. Say as little as possible.

Don’t call only to let a collector bully you or make you uncomfortable. When you know your rights and the truth about the debt, you can do this. Ask the questions. Remember, you don’t have to answer any at this time, but by law the collector does.

From this advice comes the second tenet: Don’t volunteer anything about income, property, or bank accounts. You can agree on a payment plan later. During this first call, you need to get all the data you can about the collector’s claims. One-word answers are fine. Don’t tell sob stories, and definitely don’t make promises like, “I’ll pay,” which could be interpreted as a contract in some cases.

As for specifics, here’s what to ask: Get the name of the firm, the creditor and the amount. Ask for a breakdown, if possible. These questions are the beginning of a process called “validation.” Then, tell the collector you want the name and address of the original creditor, along with any account numbers tied to the debt. You can also ask for other evidence the collector may have, such as a judgment. You may have to send a written request to file a formal dispute in order to obtain that information, but debt collectors sometimes offer it straight away.

Do all the above firmly but politely. Remember, you might end up negotiating with the collector. There’s no reason to be rude or hostile — just be firm and say very little.

During this initial call, don’t keep your credit card or checkbook nearby. If the collector makes threats, even veiled ones, like ‘I’m sure you don’t want me to call your workplace about this,” that’s a sign something is wrong, and it’s critical for you to get off the phone as soon as possible.

The biggest don’t of all is not being talked into making some kind of small “good faith” payment towards the debt. That’s often a trick debt collectors use to get consumers to pay debts they don’t legally owe. Any payment can restart the statute of limitations clock, re-aging the debt.

After the Call

The statute of limitations issue is one reason to hang up, digest what you’ve collected and make a thoughtful payment plan. When you get all the information you are legally entitled to, you can then make a plan of action. Again, be active, not passive. If the debt isn’t yours, you can begin the formal debt dispute process. If you feel like the debt is accurate but the late/penalty fees are unfair, you can try to negotiate with the collector or dispute the overages.

If you are ready to start paying but want gentler terms, make a budget and call the collector to make an offer. Hold firm and don’t answer questions like, “How much money do you have in your 401(k)?” Just make your offer.

This is also the time to realistically look at your family budget and decide if you can or can’t pay your bills. If you can’t, consider talking to a bankruptcy attorney before you call the collector back.

The biggest mistake consumers filing for bankruptcy make is filing too late. Many raid retirement accounts or make other foolish last-ditch efforts to pay bills, so they lose assets that could have been preserved in the process.

That debt collector call, however scary, could be a sign it’s time to admit the depth of the problem and the need for dramatic steps to make it right.

More on Managing Debt:

Image: Wavebreak Media Ltd

The post 3 Things to Do Before Calling Back a Debt Collector appeared first on

What Is a Debt Collector Required to Tell Me?

Struggling to pay off a mountain of debt can be a very stressful experience. It gets even worse when debt collectors enter the picture. The phone calls, the hounding, the past-due notices that flood your mailbox — they’re enough to make you silence your phone and ignore your mail. But burying your head in the sand won’t make the bills or the collectors go away.

What can alleviate some of that stress is knowing your rights when it comes to debt collection and exercising them as quickly as possible.

Get Written Notice

First and foremost, a debt collector can’t just call and tell you that you owe a debt. They must provide written notice within five days of contacting you, outlining the amount of money you owe, the name of the creditor and any other pertinent details. This notice also must explain what actions to take if you believe you do not owe the money.

Troy Doucet, an attorney focused on debtor rights, said the letter must also explain that a consumer has the right to challenge the validity of the debt within 30 days of receiving the notice and that not challenging it does not necessarily mean the consumer agrees it is valid.

“Also, the law requires that any communication, whether written or on the phone, includes a statement that they are a debt collector and the purpose of the communication is to collect on a debt,” he said.

It’s also important to remember that the obligation to validate the debt is on the collector, not the consumer. As such, if you do challenge the debt, the collector must verify the debt and notify you in writing before they renew collection calls.

You Can Say ‘Stop Calling Me!’

You can tell collectors to stop calling you — and you may want to, particularly if you believe the debt is erroneous. They have to stop contacting you if you send a letter requesting that they do so, and if you believe you do not owe the money, you should also say that in your letter. Be aware that a legitimate debt will not go away simply because the collection calls stop. You could still be sued by the debt collector or your original creditor for the amount that you owe.

Know the Statute of Limitations

Debt collectors are regulated by state laws, and every state has a different statute of limitations that limits how long a creditor or debt collector can attempt to collect a debt. Typically, the statute of limitations starts when you miss your first payment with the original creditor. It does not start when the account was placed for collection. You can review a state-by-state map of these statutes of limitation here.

Remember the very first person who must stand up for your debt collection rights is you. So don’t let a debt collector intimidate you or harass you with unfair and illegal debt collection tactics. If you need specific assistance and advice, contact an attorney.

Know What’s In Your Credit Report

Regularly keeping track of your debts on your credit report can help immensely if you are ever contacted by a debt collector, and can help you spot early on any bogus or fraudulent debts. You can can check your two free credit scores, updated every month on In general, you can fix your credit by disputing any errors on your credit report, identifying credit score killers and coming up with a game plan to address those issues — before the debt collectors come knocking.

More on Credit Reports & Credit Scores:

Image: Mixmike

The post What Is a Debt Collector Required to Tell Me? appeared first on

Will the Obama Administration Side With Debt Collectors?


With the Supreme Court in flux, the highest authority in U.S. law has punted a landmark case over to the executive branch, effectively asking it to decide whether debt collectors can charge interest rates so high they’re deemed illegal in some states.

In Madden v. Midland Funding, LLC., a debt collection company purchased the plaintiff’s charged-off debt, but the plaintiff resided in New York state where the usury limit is 25% annually. The complaint was simple. Midland had tried to collect 27%, two points more than the state usury laws allowed. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit decided in the plaintiff’s favor, taking the view that the two percentage points over the state usury limit violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.

The question answered by the 2nd Circuit had nothing to do with whether or not debt collectors should be allowed to hunt and potentially mortally wound those who are not financially strong — but more simply what sort of weaponry they should be able to use to do so.

Bazooka or Pellet Gun: The Problem

Madden v. Midland Funding LLC is a classic manifestation of our nation’s often rudderless approach to consumer financial safeguards.

For those who follow these things, it won’t be news that the lack of steerage has absolutely nothing to do with any inherent design flaw. The basics of the banking system’s ability to extend loans and charge interest on them established by Alexander Hamilton still works fine. Having said this, that system has sustained damage on the many rocks and reefs of patchwork legislation over the years, laws and regulations aimed specifically at empowering the lender—with the exception of extreme cases like loan sharking and other RICO offenses—over the interests of the borrower.

Necessary Background

A 1978 Supreme Court case, Marquette Nat. Bank of Minneapolis v. First of Omaha Service Corp., decided that the National Banking Act of 1863 allowed a national bank to charge the interest rate of the state in which it was headquartered, regardless the rates applicable in the state where a borrower resides.

In 1980, Congress passed the Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act, which exempted federally chartered installment plan lenders from state usury limits. This is the underlying reason so many lenders scurried to set up shop in states like South Dakota and Delaware. They offer the most bank-favorable terms.

Now, under the post-Marquette reading of the National Banking Act, any nationally chartered bank could charge 27% interest, so long as it wasn’t headquartered in New York State, but that “professional courtesy” proffered by various lender-friendly generations of lawmakers could not be extended to Midland Funding. The reason: It is a non-bank. Therefore, the decision found, state usury laws applied.

The decision created quite a stir, because if upheld, many folks in the financial world argued, it would create Byzantine layers of complication since states have different applicable rates. First of all: this is ridiculous. There are already countless state and local laws that govern how debt collectors, banks and non-banks operate. One more is meaningless.

Meanwhile, the fate of countless consumers in the sights of debt collectors will be decided by the Obama administration, which has been asked to file a brief “expressing the views of the United States” in the matter of Madden v. Midland Funding LLC.

Pending Justice Antonin Scalia’s replacement, four votes are needed to get the case heard before the Supreme Court. Clearly, they don’t have the votes, and they are looking for some guidance on the matter from the president, or more precisely, from Obama’s Solicitor General Donald Verrilli.

What Should the Solicitor General Do?

Is it too blunt to say merely, “Duh?” There will always be a hunter-hunted component in the world of consumer debt collection. At issue is to what extent that will be allowed. Depending on the Solicitor General’s decision on behalf of this Administration, non-bank entities will either have to fish using the catch-and-release method, or they’ll get to use dynamite.

Right now, with Madden in the balance, the prevailing interpretation of the law allows abuses to occur. The 2nd Circuit decision suggests a new, more consumer-friendly chapter in consumer financial protections. Hopefully, Mr. Verrilli will decide that the 2nd Circuit got it right.

This story is an Op/Ed contribution to and does not necessarily represent the views of the company or its partners.

More on Managing Debt:

Image: David Sacks

The post Will the Obama Administration Side With Debt Collectors? appeared first on

Debt Collectors Went After a Student Loan Debt… 50 Years Later

Young people aren’t the only ones plagued with student loan debt problems. Recently, an Arizona man found a debt collection notice in his mailbox, which said he owed more than $1,900 on student loans he took out in the 1960s, reports 3TV in Phoenix.

About 50 years ago, after serving in the Navy, Ralph Caswell borrowed three loans totaling about $2,500. Caswell told 3TV he repaid the student loans decades ago, and while the collection agency shows his principal balance as zero, it claims Caswell owes about $1,400 in interest, $87 for a penalty and $362 in fees. Caswell said the agency asked him to provide proof he paid off the loans, but he doesn’t have those records. That’s not too surprising, considering how long ago he said he paid off the debt.

This situation suggests you should keep that type of documentation forever: alongside your birth certificate, Social Security card and passport, there’s your student loan statement. While that may sound a little overboard, it’s important to note that student loan debt is treated differently than other debts in many respects. These loans can generally not be written off in bankruptcy, and the consequences of failing to repay student loan debt can follow you for years. If you don’t repay federal student loans, the government can take some of your wages, seize your tax refunds or garnish Social Security payments.

There are lots of rules governing debt collectors’ actions and the timeframe of debt collection, and it’s important that consumers generally understand their rights when trying to resolve new (and old) issues.

Caswell will now have to work out whether he owes the debt with the collector — and, possibly, a consumer attorney. He found out about the claim when he got a notice in the mail, but it will probably show up on his credit report, if it hasn’t already. (Caswell told 3TV he currently has good credit.) Regularly reviewing your credit reports can help you spot surprises like this and potentially resolve them more quickly. You can get your credit reports for free each year on and view your credit scores for free each month on If you think items on your reports are incorrect, here’s a guide to credit reporting errors and how they happen.

More on Managing Debt:

Image: Ben Blankenburg

The post Debt Collectors Went After a Student Loan Debt… 50 Years Later appeared first on